Mankind has a long history of experience with
bandwidth-limited channels. As you can see here, in 350 B.C. the
bandwidth of this channel was limited by the speed of the slave's arm,
and the accuracy of the water-clock.
-----------------------
Here is the story of the signaling system of Aneas, as
told in "The Early History of Data Networks", by Gerard J. Horlzmann and
Bjorn Pehrson, IEEE Computer Society Press, 1994 ISBN 0-8186-6782-6. I
quote from p. 24,
Polybius, in The Histories, Book X, describes:
The first person who we reliably know developed a telegraph was Aeneas
(not the Aeneas from Vergil's Aeneid.) Aeneas was a well-known author in
ancient Greece, who lived around 350 B.C. and wrote works on military
strategy. Only part of his main work, "The Art of War", still exists,
and unfortunately it does not contain the description of his telegraph.
We do have a clear description of Aeneas's design by the historian
Polybius (ca. 200-118 B.C.). In "The Histories" Polybius first
described, in crystal-clear prose, the limitations of plain beacon
fires.
"I think that as regards the system of signaling by fire, which is now
of the greatest possible service in war but was formerly underdeveloped,
it will be of use not to pass it over but to give it a proper
discussion. It is evident to all that in every matter, and especially in
warfare, the power of acting at the right time contributes very much to
the success of enterprises, and fire signals are the most efficient of
all the devices which aid us to do this. For they show what has recently
occurred and what is still in the course of being done, and by means of
them anyone who cares to do so even if he is at a distance of three,
four, or even more days' journey can be informed. So that it is always
surprising how help can be brought be means of fire messages when the
situation requires it. Now in former times, as fire signals were simple
beacons, they were for the most part of little use to those who used
them. For the service should have been performed by signals previously
determined upon, and as facts are indefinite, most ot them defied
communication by fire signals. To take the case I just mentioned, it was
possible for those who had agreed on this to convey information that a
fleet had arrived at Oreus, Peparethus, or Chalcis, but when it came to
some of the citizens having changed sides or having been guilty of
treachery or a massacre having taken place in the town, or anything of
the kind, things that often happen, but cannot all be foreseen--and it
is chiefly unexpected occurrences which require instant consideration
and help-- all such matters defied communication by fire signal. For it
was quite impossible to have a pre-concerted code for things which there
was no means of foretelling."
(continued on next page)